Local Scope SEO
Home / Answers / How to tell if an SEO agency is legit

Hiring an agency

How can I tell if an SEO agency is legit?

By Brayton Taylor, Co-founder, Local Scope SEO. Updated

Short answer

A legit SEO agency tells you what it will do, what it costs and how you'll measure it, and never promises a #1 ranking. Google itself says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and warns against SEOs that claim a special relationship with Google.

Legit or red flag

CheckA legit agencyA red flag
RankingsExplains what affects themGuarantees #1 (Google)
GoogleFollows Google's published rulesClaims a "special relationship" or "priority submit" (Google)
PricePublished, or a written quoteWon't say until a long sales call
Your accountsIn your name, agency added as a userAgency owns them (Google says an agency must set up a separate Ads account for you)
ReviewsNamed clients with numbers you can checkAnonymous praise; fake and AI-written reviews are banned by the FTC
How they found youYou found themAn email out of the blue (Google)

What it means for your business

  • Ask for two clients you can call, and check reviews on a site the agency doesn't control.
  • Ask what you'll see each month. Calls, leads and cost per lead are real; a list of rankings alone is not enough.
  • Get the agreement in writing, with the price, minimum term and how to cancel.
  • If they won't explain what they'll change on your site, that's a reason to walk.

Where Local Scope SEO fits

Our prices are on our pricing page, every account stays in your name, and our case studies name the client. One of them, Andrew, owner of Summit Home Inspections, put it this way: "Our previous marketing agency sold us on guaranteeing they could reduce our cost per lead, but no one delivered as quickly as Local Scope SEO."

Every plan and what it includes is on our pricing page.

Local Scope SEO sells the services discussed here. Compare our published plans and terms with other providers and your own results.

Common follow-up questions

Is it a red flag if an SEO agency guarantees rankings?

Yes. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google, and tells site owners to beware of SEOs that claim to (Google).

Are low prices a red flag?

Not by themselves. Ask what's included each month. A low price with a clear inclusion list is fine; a low price with vague promises isn't.

How do I check an agency's reviews?

Look for named clients, results with numbers, and reviews on third-party sites. Ask to speak to a current client.

Want this answered for your business?

Book a free 30-minute call. We'll look at your Google profile, your market and your competitors, and tell you what we'd do first and what it would cost.